公理戰勝 Justice Triumphs

Justice Triumphs

公理战胜

That night the first commemorative ceremony of victory was to be held; people who had never tasted the bitterness of war rushed to have a taste

那晚上要举行战胜纪念第一次底典礼,不曾尝过战苦底人们争着要尝一尝

滿of the sweetness that comes after war. Before seven o'clock, the crowd in front of the ceremony grounds had already packed the place.

战后底甘味.式场前头底人,未到七点钟,早就挤满了.

,『From over there a voice said, "You've come too!?』Did you come to celebrate the triumph of justice?" From this side came the reply,

那边一个声音说,『你也来了!你可是为庆贺公理战胜来底?』这边随着囘答

,『.』"I only came to watch the excitement — what do I care whether justice triumphs or not."

道,『我只来瞧热闹,管他公理战胜不战胜.』

,『In my ear, as if in a trance, I heard someone speaking with a rustic country accent say, "A foreign emperor's birthday beats everything else for

在我耳边恍惚有一个说话带乡下土腔底说,『一个洋皇上生日倒比什么都

!』liveliness!"

热闹!』

My friend laughed.

,『.』I said to him solemnly, "Listen to that foolish remark — it actually makes a good deal of sense."

我郑重地对他说,『你听这愚拙的话,倒很入理.』

——.』"I believe it too — that is, if you say the god of war is a foreign emperor."

『我也信——若说战神是洋皇帝底话.』

:『.』Voices, music, gunfire, and all sorts of other clamor mingled together, almost splitting our eardrums. My friend said, "Look, over there they're getting ready to set off fireworks — let's go over and watch."

人声,乐声,鎗声,和等等杂响混在一处,几乎把我们底耳鼓震裂了.我底朋友说:『你看,那边预备放烟花了,我们过去看看罢.』

.『!』We stood at a distance, watching the red, yellow, blue, and white sparks rise up one after another. "This is wonderful, this is wonderful!" Many

我们远远站着,看那红黄蓝白诸色火花次第地冒上来.『这真好,这真好!』许

people praised it just so. But was this really praise for the triumph of justice?

多人都是这样颂扬.但这是不是颂扬公理战胜?

,『Someone beside us said, "These brilliant fireworks of yours — how are they anything but the flames of hell?If there truly is a hell,

旁边有一个人说,『你这灿烂的烟花,何尝不是地狱底火燄?若是真有个地狱,

.』I imagine the flames within it are just as beautiful to behold."

我想其中的火燄也是这般好看.』

,『My friend said to me in a low voice, "That's right — aren't these fireworks here precisely because we are commemorating the war dead?The suffering of those who died in battle —

我底朋友低声对我说,『对呀,这烟花岂不是从纪念战死底人而来底?战死底

.』that we never tasted; but the flames of hell revealed by their deaths, those we have indeed seen."

苦我们没有尝到,由战死而显出来底地狱火燄我们倒看见了.』

:『I said, "So our coming here tonight is not to join in the merrymaking, but to mourn those foolish, pitiable victims of sacri-

我说:『所以我们今晚的来,不是要趁热闹,乃是要凭吊那班愚昧可怜的牺牲

.』-fice."

Talk as we might, the fireworks went on being set off just the same. Our voices were forever swallowed up in the seething sea of people.

谈论尽管谈论,烟花还是一样地放.我们底声音常是沦没在腾沸的人海里.

Loading the interactive reader…

What it’s about

Crowds gather for the first anniversary celebration of victory, eager to taste postwar sweetness without having tasted war. Some admit they came only for spectacle; a rustic voice mistakes the ceremony for a foreign emperor's birthday. Music, guns and noise nearly rupture the listeners' eardrums. Multicolored fireworks rise while spectators praise their beauty, though no one can say that such praise is directed toward justice itself.

A bystander compares the brilliant display to flames in hell. The narrator and his friend agree that fireworks commemorating the war dead let safe spectators enjoy an image of suffering they escaped. They redefine their attendance as mourning for pitiable sacrifices, but their conversation is drowned by the boiling human sea as the display continues unchanged. The triumphant title is thus bitterly unstable: public claims of moral victory become entertainment powered by distance from actual death.

When it was written 背景

The celebration is the first anniversary of the Allied victory in the First World War, publicly hailed in China with the slogan 公理戰勝 after Germany's defeat. That optimism soon collided with the Paris settlement's transfer of German rights in Shandong to Japan, helping provoke the May Fourth movement. Xu focuses less on diplomacy than spectatorship: gunlike noise and fiery beauty reproduce war as festival. Learners should track 嘗, 熱鬧, 頜揚 and 憑弔. Each tests whether people who consume a commemoration can truthfully claim either victory or mourning.

Words in this chapter 生词